Apartments for Family and Local Renters
Southold’s accessory apartment rules are written for family and local renters, not the open market. A May 2025 amendment set the current terms, reported by the Suffolk Times. The owner or a family member lives in one unit. The tenant is family, or a Southold resident on the Town’s Affordable Housing Registry. Leases run at least two years, and rental permits can’t be transferred. Each apartment goes through Zoning Board of Appeals review.
A 2026 amendment loosened one thing. It dropped the requirement that the apartment be inside a “permanently existing” home and now allows new detached accessory structures.
That’s a long way from News 12’s August 2026 summary, which put Southold in the “not allowed” column. What neither the Town’s changes nor the reporting covers is the basement. We haven’t seen anything that says whether an accessory apartment in a Southold basement qualifies, so ask before you plan one.

Working with the Southold Building Department
Southold Town Hall is at 53095 Main Road, Southold, with a main line of (631) 765-1889. Ask for the Southold Building Department there. Town offices are split between Town Hall and the Town Annex on Route 25. Ask Town Hall for the Building Department’s direct line and the current permit application when you call. The state rule, 19 NYCRR 1203.3, is enough to answer the main question: cutting a new opening in a foundation has no permit exemption, so an egress window needs a permit.
Greenport is the town’s one incorporated village and handles its own permits. Egress window permits on Long Island covers what departments usually ask for.
If an apartment is the goal, the order matters. Zoning Board of Appeals review and any county septic review come first, because they decide whether the unit can exist at all. The building permit follows, and install day comes last. Cutting a foundation before the board has ruled is the expensive way to find out the answer is no. Any bedroom in the unit still needs an emergency escape opening under the state code, whatever the board decides about the apartment. Mattituck, Cutchogue, Southold hamlet, Peconic, Orient, and East Marion file with the Town.

North Fork Conditions
If a Southold apartment adds a unit to a house on septic, Suffolk County Department of Health Services reviews it on its accessory apartment form, WWM-105. A bedroom for your own household doesn’t add a unit, so it doesn’t trigger that step.
For a basement entrance, drainage is one of the things that moves the price, alongside size, materials and excavation.

The Install
Southold hamlet is one of the North Fork places where we’ve already installed egress windows.
For an egress window install, we cut the opening and set a window that meets the 2025 NY code: 5.7 sq ft of net clear opening (5.0 only for a grade-floor opening), at least 24 inches high and 20 wide, with the sill no more than 44 inches from the floor. The well is at least 9 sq ft and 36 inches out from the wall, with a ladder or steps if it’s deeper than 44 inches. Most installs take one day, and we’ll give you the schedule with your quote.
Installed egress windows start at $5,900 with a masonry well and $6,500 with a Boman Kemp steel well. A Cambridge ArmorTec segmental block well starts at $8,900 up to 40 inches deep, plus $1,100 per extra 12 inches. A basement entrance is $12,000 to $15,000 (egress window cost on Long Island). Compare Southold with Riverhead, Shelter Island and the rest of the East End on the basement apartment rules page, or call (516) 390-8891.

Can a Southold accessory apartment be rented to anyone?
No. Tenants must be family or Southold residents on the Town's Affordable Housing Registry, on a lease of at least two years, and the rental permit can't be transferred to a new owner. The owner or a family member also has to live in one of the units, and each apartment goes through Zoning Board of Appeals review first.
Does Southold allow detached accessory apartments?
Yes, since a 2026 amendment reported by the Suffolk Times. It removed the requirement that the apartment be inside a permanently existing home and allows new detached accessory structures. That doesn't settle whether a basement unit qualifies, which the reporting doesn't cover, so ask the Town before planning egress windows around one.
How do I reach the Southold Building Department?
Start with Town Hall at 53095 Main Road, Southold, on the main line, (631) 765-1889, and ask for the Building Department. Town offices are split between Town Hall and the Town Annex on Route 25. If your house is in the Village of Greenport, call the village instead, since it handles its own permits.
- Suffolk Times, ADU changes greenlit by Southold Town Board, May 2025
- Suffolk Times, Southold allows detached accessory apartments, April 2026
- Suffolk County Department of Health Services, residential wastewater permits
- News 12 Long Island, "Think the basement apartment is legal on LI? It depends on your town," August 2026
- 19 NYCRR 1203.3, building permit requirements (Justia copy)
- List of municipalities on Long Island, Wikipedia
- 2024 IRC section R319.2, ICC Digital Codes
Last reviewed October 21, 2026.



