Working with the Shelter Island Building Department
Plans come first, then the window. Shelter Island’s building permit application, revised July 1, 2025, is specific about what comes with it, and most of it applies to an egress window:
- Two sets of plans stamped by an architect or engineer (more on the permit process for egress windows).
- A survey, which the Town may waive for interior work that doesn’t affect setbacks. A new foundation opening and an outside well are exterior work, so plan on one.
- An energy certificate with the window U-factors, which means the window has to be chosen before you file.
- Suffolk County Health approval where it’s required.
On waterfront or low-lying lots, the survey must show flood zone boundaries for new construction. The Building Department is at 38 North Ferry Road, (631) 749-0772, Monday to Friday 8 to 4.

Accessory Apartments Under § 133-17
News 12’s August 2026 summary listed Shelter Island as allowing basement apartments with permits. The Town Code allows accessory apartments in every district, with conditions. The owner lives in one of the units. Leases are year-round, one year or longer. The apartment is at least 480 sq ft with no more than two bedrooms. The license renews every two years with an inspection, and the Town caps new licenses each year. New apartments aren’t allowed in the Near Shore and Peninsula Overlay District.
The code doesn’t address basements. Whether a basement unit can meet the 480 sq ft minimum and the rest is a question for the Building Department before it’s one for us.

Water and Sewage Come First
Shelter Island won’t issue an apartment license until Suffolk County Department of Health Services has approved water and sewage. The county has a separate accessory apartment application, form WWM-105, through its Office of Wastewater Management in Hauppauge, (631) 852-5700. Build that review into your timeline. It’s a separate office from the Town, and the license waits on it.

Shelter Island Heights and Dering Harbor
Shelter Island and Shelter Island Heights file with the Town. Dering Harbor is an incorporated village with its own rules, so check there first if your house is inside the village. Across the water, Southold and East Hampton each run their own departments, and the East End page compares all five towns.

The Work
The egress window itself is held to the same state minimums as the rest of Long Island (what an egress window install involves): 5.7 sq ft of net clear opening (5.0 only for a grade-floor opening), 24 inches high and 20 wide at minimum, sill no higher than 44 inches, and a well at least 9 sq ft with 36 inches of projection. Wells deeper than 44 inches need a ladder or steps. Most egress window installs take one day. The wall and the weather can add time, and the schedule comes with your quote.
Egress windows start at $5,900 installed with a masonry well, $6,500 with a Boman Kemp galvanized steel well and $8,900 with a Cambridge ArmorTec well up to 40 inches deep ($1,100 per extra 12 inches). A basement entrance is $12,000 to $15,000 (how we price an egress window). The window you choose also goes on the energy certificate, so the model has to be picked before you file. Read the NY egress requirements and the apartment rules by town, then call (516) 390-8891.

How big must an accessory apartment be on Shelter Island?
At least 480 sq ft, with no more than two bedrooms, under Town Code § 133-17. The owner has to live in one of the units, and leases run year-round for at least a year. The code doesn't address basements, so whether a basement unit can meet the size rule and the rest is a question for the Building Department.
Can I add an accessory apartment anywhere on Shelter Island?
Almost. The Town allows accessory apartments in every district, except that new ones aren't allowed in the Near Shore and Peninsula Overlay District. The Town also caps how many new licenses it issues each year, and Suffolk County Department of Health Services has to approve water and sewage before a license is issued.
How often is a Shelter Island apartment license renewed?
Every two years, with an inspection, under Town Code § 133-17. Expect the inspector to look at the unit itself, so keep each bedroom's egress window able to open fully and its well clear of leaves, snow and stored items. A blocked well is one of the easier problems to fix before the visit, and one of the more serious to leave.
Does my survey need to show the flood zone?
For new construction on waterfront or low-lying lots, yes. The Town's July 2025 building permit application says the survey must show flood zone boundaries. A survey may be waived for interior work that doesn't affect setbacks, but a new foundation opening with a well outside is exterior work, so plan on supplying one.
- Town of Shelter Island Code, § 133-17 accessory apartments
- Town of Shelter Island, Building Permit Application, July 2025
- Town of Shelter Island, Building Department
- Suffolk County Department of Health Services, residential wastewater permits
- List of municipalities on Long Island, Wikipedia
- 2024 IRC section R319.2, ICC Digital Codes
- NYS Department of State, notice of adoption of the 2025 Uniform Code
Last reviewed October 21, 2026.




